Sivga P2 Pro vs SV023

Sivga has quickly gained recognition for its high-quality craftsmanship and exceptional sound offerings. Established in 2016, Sivga has since released several well-received headphones, including the Phoenix, Luan, and original P-II. However, two models stand out in particular: the brand new Sivga P2 Pro and the fan favorite Sivga SV023. These headphones represent different approaches to design and audio engineering, appealing to both planar magnetic and dynamic driver enthusiasts. With both coming in at $449, which one offers the better overall performance? 

What’s in the Box:

Build Quality

Both the P2 Pro and SV023 feature Sivga’s signature wood housing, showcasing a strong commitment to aesthetics and build quality. However, each model takes a unique approach to this aspect, with differences that may influence the user experience. The P2 Pro features fine red oak wood ear cups, offering a lighter and more visually striking appearance compared to the darker walnut used in its predecessor, the P2. The build incorporates a combination of metal for the yokes and support, with leather-like materials for the headband. The overall construction is sturdy and premium. At 435 grams, the P2 Pro feels solid without being too heavy. The ear cups also swivel, offering better adjustability, while the angled ear pads provide an ergonomic fit that enhances comfort during long listening sessions.

The SV023 also uses wooden ear cups, though it uses the same dark walnut as was used on the original P2. While the wood is darker and more traditional in appearance, it exudes a classic, high-end feel. The headphone features an aluminum frame and a suspension headband, similar to the one found on the P2 Pro, contributing to a lightweight design that offers both durability and comfort. The perforated memory foam ear pads, covered in velvet, provide a cozy and plush experience. It also weighs in at a significantly lower 318 grams, making the SV023 an excellent option for extended listening.

If you prefer a more modern, eye-catching design, the P2 Pro’s lighter wood and metal accents may be more appealing. However, for those who appreciate classic aesthetics and a slightly more traditional approach, the SV023 with its walnut wood finish may be the winner. Both models are exceptionally well-built, with comfort in mind.

Design

One of the biggest differences between the two models lies in their driver technology, which ultimately shapes their sound signature. The P2 Pro utilizes a 97 x 76mm planar magnetic driver, known for delivering excellent detail and clarity across the frequency range. Sivga improved upon the original P2 design by using lithography technology to craft the coil on the driver diaphragm. This manufacturing process allows for a cleaner, more accurate sound reproduction. Planar magnetic drivers are known for their speed and transient response, making the P2 Pro ideal for those who prioritize detail and resolution in their listening experience. It has an impedance of 32 ohms, making it relatively easy to drive, though an amp is recommended for the best experience.

In contrast, the SV023 uses a 50mm dynamic driver with an LCP (Liquid Crystal Polymer) composite diaphragm that’s plated with beryllium. The SV023 also features a With an impedance of 300 ohms, the SV023 is much more demanding in terms of power, making a high-quality amplifier an essential part of the setup.

Driver choice will ultimately come down to personal preference. What counts is that both headphones require some amount of external power. But as for how the two headphones actually wind up sounding? Well, let’s get into that next. 

Sound Impressions

Low End:

The Sivga P2 Pro offers an engaging bass response that is timbrally warm while maintaining a solid level of detail. The planar magnetic drivers contribute to a tactile and visceral low-end, with good depth but without overwhelming the other frequencies. While not the most pronounced or heavy-handed in terms of sub-bass rumble, it excels in delivering a well-rounded and musical low end. Overall, the P2 Pro’s low-end performance is rooted in quality rather than quantity, appealing to listeners who appreciate subtlety and musicality over pure bombast.

The bass on the Sivga SV023 on the other hand is a bit more neutral when compared to the P2 Pro. The 50mm dynamic driver, paired with the beryllium-plated diaphragm, provides a punchy and responsive low-end, with plenty of space for texture and layering. The SV023’s bass doesn’t overwhelm the listener but instead offers a more natural and smooth response, especially noticeable with acoustic instruments like bass guitars and drums. It has depth and clarity, but rather than rumble or shake, it focuses on delivering a balanced, textured bass that enhances the overall sound signature. This makes it particularly suited to listeners who enjoy bass that is clean and well-integrated rather than overpowering.

Mid-Range:

The midrange is where the P2 Pro truly shines, with a rich and smooth presentation that brings vocals and instruments to life. There’s a sweet warmth here that adds depth to vocals, allowing them to stand out without becoming overly forward or shouty. The mids maintain a sense of musicality that is engaging without sacrificing detail, making it the standout frequency range of this headphone.

The SV023’s midrange is lively and expansive, with an excellent sense of space and separation. Vocals and mid-range instruments are presented with remarkable clarity and detail, allowing the listener to pick out individual elements in a track without any of them competing for attention. The SV023 excels at delivering a natural and transparent midrange, where the energy is forward enough to engage the listener but balanced enough to avoid midrange fatigue. The midrange is vibrant and precise, offering a clean and transparent experience.

Top End:

The treble on the Sivga P2 Pro is crisp and detailed without being overly bright. The planar magnetic driver allows for excellent high-frequency resolution, with a shimmer that complements the warm low end. The top end strikes a delicate balance, offering sparkle and airiness without causing listening fatigue, even during extended sessions. The treble remains articulate and clean, contributing to an overall balanced but rich sound signature that is easy to listen to for long periods.

The treble on the SV023 is highly resolving, with a slight sparkle that enhances high-frequency details without becoming harsh or fatiguing. The highs are crisp and clear, bringing out nuances in instruments like cymbals, strings, and high-pitched vocals. There’s a certain bite to the upper frequencies that gives the sound signature some excitement, but it remains controlled enough to avoid sibilance or harshness in aggressive tracks. The clarity in the top end contributes to the overall sense of openness and resolution, making the SV023 a great choice for those who appreciate detailed treble without any artificial brightness.

Soundstage:

The soundstage of the P2 Pro is moderately wide, though not as expansive as some other open-back planar magnetic headphones. That said, it offers good dimensionality and accurate imaging, with instruments placed clearly within the stereo field. The soundstage creates a sense of space that’s immersive without feeling overly distant or exaggerated. While not the most “airy” presentation, the P2 Pro does a great job at layering sounds, giving a natural sense of depth. This controlled soundstage makes the P2 Pro a versatile option for a variety of genres, from intimate acoustic performances to larger, more complex arrangements.

Meanwhile, SV023 truly excels in its soundstage. The open-back design, combined with the dynamic driver, creates an expansive and airy soundstage that feels wide and immersive. The headphone’s ability to layer sounds and position instruments accurately within the stereo field adds to the sense of space. This makes the listener feel as though they are in the room with the performers. Acoustic and live recordings particularly benefit from this spacious presentation. The soundstage on the SV023 is expansive without sacrificing accuracy, offering an enveloping and realistic listening experience.

Conclusion

On the surface, these two headphones don’t look all too dissimilar. Yes the P2 Pro has lighter wood and has a larger grill than the SV023, but they’re ultimately beautifully crafted wood headphones. But their internal designs make for two sets of cans which are totally unique from each other. And at the same price, it’s important to consider which is really the right one for you.

If you prefer a more reference-neutral headphone, the SV023 is probably up your alley. It manages a nimble but not overdone bass, clear and transparent mids, and linear but still sparkly top end. But if you want something more musical and with a more unique sound signature, then the more fun P2 Pro probably has you covered. Its warm and creamy approach to music will be sure to make for some fun listening. 

The Sivga P2 Pro and SV023 are both available at Audio46.